ホーム出版社ガイドライン wiley vs sage vs world scientific publishing vs elsevier ai guidelines

AIを使用した論文作成と投稿に関する出版社ガイドラインのまとめ

幾つかの出版社が著者向けに公開しているAI使用に関するガイドラインの主要ポイントを表形式でまとめました。研究および原稿作成においてAIツールを使用することについて、出版社が何を求めているかをポイントや用途ごとに比較します。

スムーズな研究と論文執筆、および投稿のご参考として、研究者・論文著者の皆さまにご活用いただければ幸いです。

出版社を選択

比較する出版社	Elsevier	SAGE	Wiley	World Scientific Publishing

Refine, correct, edit, or format the manuscript to improve clarity of language.	allowed	allowed	allowed	not defined
Human Review of AI Output	required	not defined	required	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	required	not required	not required	not defined
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	required	not defined	not required	not defined

Writing or drafting manuscript content	allowed	allowed	allowed	allowed
Human Review of AI Output	required	required	required	not defined
Human Review for assessing rewritten content to ensure expertise, voice, and originality is maintained.	required	required	required	not defined
Human Review for potential for bias	not defined	not defined	required	not defined
Human Review for inaccurate attribution	not defined	required	required	not defined
Human Review to ensure tone and style align with the manuscript	not defined	not defined	required	not defined
Human Review for fact checking	required	required	required	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	required	required	required	required
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	required	required	required	not defined

Translation of manuscript text for the purpose of publishing	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review of AI Output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review for assessing translated rewritten content to ensure expertise, voice, and originality is maintained	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review for potential for bias	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review for inaccurate attribution	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review to ensure tone and style align with the manuscript	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review for fact checking	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not defined	required	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined

Refining or formatting of data reported in the submitted manuscript	not allowed	not allowed	not defined	allowed
Human Review of AI Output	not applicable	not applicable	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not applicable	not applicable	not defined	required
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not applicable	not applicable	not defined	not defined

Generation, refinement, correction, editing or formatting of images, diagrams or other figures for illustrative purposes only	not allowed	not defined	allowed	allowed
Human Review of AI Output	not applicable	not defined	required	not defined
Human Review to check if images are accurate and not misrepresent information	not applicable	not defined	required	not defined
Human Review to check if illustrations effectively communicate key concepts	not applicable	not defined	required	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not applicable	not defined	required	required
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not applicable	not defined	required	not defined

AI tools used to generate, modify, or enhance images that support specific scientific, clinical, or technical claims	not defined	not allowed	not allowed	not defined

Generation, refinement, correction, editing or formatting of visualisations of research data or results	not allowed	not allowed	not allowed	not defined
Human Review of AI Output	not applicable	not applicable	not applicable	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not applicable	not applicable	not applicable	not defined
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not applicable	not applicable	not applicable	not defined

Refinement or formatting of code reported in the submitted manuscript	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review of AI Output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined

Assisting with compilation of reference lists	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Human Review of AI Output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of use of AI tools	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined
Disclosure of Human verification of AI output	not defined	not defined	not defined	not defined

Presentation of any kind of content generated by AI as though it were original research data/results from non-machine sources	not defined	not allowed	not allowed	not defined

Official AI Policy Guide Link	Elsevier AI Policy	SAGE AI Policy	Wiley AI Policy	World Scientific Publishing AI Policy

Last Updated	-	-	-	-

AIを使用した論文作成と投稿に関する出版社ガイドラインのまとめ

ここに掲載されていな情報をご希望の場合は以下よりご連絡ください。